MyFox
 

Asleep at the Wheel

by TexasGuyDFW from The Dew Drop Inn

Last Post 4 days, 2 hours Ago


Recently I witnessed an auto accident. A motorist was traveling though an intersection with a green light at about 40mph- the posted speed. On the cross street, a motorist pulled out from behind a large, tall 4WD pickup to enter the street and make a right turn on red. Unfortunately, since the driver could not see past the truck, she ran right into the side of the car crossing the intersection. The elderly people who had the right-of-way were injured, and I expect their older model car was totaled.

I stopped to render assistance, and provide my name as a witness as something about the other driver and her car led me to believe there would be trouble. Soon, the police arrived, and I left after giving my contact info. I was contacted the next day, and told the teen driver of the vehicle at fault had no license or insurance, and I recall her older car had a dealer tag too.

I expect Medicare or Medicaid will be picking up the bill, as the older couple only had liability insurance. That means you and I pay for it through federal taxes.

Also, a good friends wife was recently hit in the rear in a school zone. She had stopped for kids in the crosswalk, when a pickup plowed into her at over 35mph. The driver of the pickup had state mandated $15,000 liability. My friend’s nearly new car was totaled, at a replacement cost of over $19,000. Their insurance has to pick up the difference, plus medical, rent car etc. since the $15,000 is not even close to paying for the car alone.

It also seems that only 50% to 60% of drivers in Texas have state mandated liability insurance, and most only carry the minimum of $15,000, which wont pay for much. That leaves those who have a few extra dollars and a fairly nice car to have to carry uninsured motorist and personal injury protection, often at a high cost.

So...

I had an idea once to add a few cents tax onto a gallon of gas here in Texas to cover "uninsured motorist" cost. The state could funnel the money to a few insurance companies to manage the insurance. Each driver without mandatory liability insurance would then have a minimum of $15,000 provided through the state fund for uninsured motorist.

If you or I wanted to have additional liability insurance, we could still get that through our insurance provider, and all our auto insurance would be a lower cost because there would be NO uninsured motorist in Texas.

Furthermore, in the event of an accident with an uninsured motorist, the party without insurance should have their vehicle auctioned to the highest bidder, with proceeds going to the "victim" first to cover their additional cost over $15,000 (if any) and the remainder going to the state to help fund the program.

This would help greatly with the illegal alien problem of no insurance, and the low income folks who simply let their $49 policies lapse after renewing their license or registration or inspection, and it also help Texans insurance rates as travelers through the state would be assisting with the cost of the fund when they buy gas.

9 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 9
Page 1 of 1
dawngoddess read my blog
Feb 18, 2008 | 4:49 PM

I was in an accident with one of those people who did NOT have insuranc..his insurance had "expired" ..his car was NOT registered to him...he had prescription pill bottles rolling all over the floor of the car and when I tried to get info from him ..he was angry because he claimed I was more interested in getting info than his injuries!!!! Got that right!!! He was to blame for the accident..I had only had the vehicle 17 days...guess who paid ??? NOT HIM!!!!!My insurance pursued him for 6 months..got nothing..he disappeared!!!!

ChopperChip read my blog view my photos
Feb 19, 2008 | 8:49 AM

What a great blog with outstanding ideas!
I guess my only problem with a tax is that everyone would be tempted to just carry the minimum amount of insurance and therefore the pool of money would evaporate quickly. To dawngoddess: Your experience is my worst fear! I'm sorry you had to go through that difficult time and now probably have to pay a higher premium for something that wasn't your fault!

TexasGuyDFW read my blog view my photos
Feb 19, 2008 | 9:41 AM

Chip,

I am not one to add to our tax burden, or have government solve all our problems, but in this case, I see it as lowering my cost, because now EVERYONE will be paying their fair share. And the more people drive, the more they will pay, which is actually even more fair.

Most people who actually have insurance only carry the minimum- $15k liability. People who have something to lose typically carry more, at higher expense to themselves. I carry a LOT more, as I understand accidents can be quite expensive. What if I hit a $100k Mercedes?

Also, keep in mind that 1/3 to 1/2 of Texas drivers don't have ANY insurance! They buy these cheap policies you see on all the billboards so they can get a card to renew a license, tag, or inspection, and simply fail to make the next payment, so the insurance is canceled. Because of this, insurance companies have raised the rates for those who DO carry insurance full time to compensate for this fact. You and I pay higher rates to cover the cost of uninsured motorist. Our rates would surely COME DOWN since EVERYONE wold be covered.

We might even want to make the minimum coverage $20k- to be realistic. And don't forget that additional insurance above this minimum can be had if needed by auctioning off the vehicle of the person at fault for not having enough insurance.

wiserb79 read my blog view my photos
Feb 21, 2008 | 4:03 PM

Texas definately needs to increase the minimum limit of liability to better match todays standards, it is very outdated. Most do not realize that increasing that limit of liability is very minimal premium for each step higher for not only the bodily injury (min. is 20 per person/ 40k per acc.) also the property damage (min. is 15k). Most of the time you can go from 20/40/15 to 50/100/50 for no more than $15 more per a 6 month policy term.
Texas also need a central database where insurance companies report to the state and people that do not carry the minimum amout of insurance either get their vehicle tags revoked or drivers license suspended. They would need to keep continuous insurance or lose these privledges and also have to pay a fee to get these back. Not only will that help those deadbeats that do not carry insurance or just don't care and also all those people that just forget and when they have an accident, oops that was just a big mistake, wont do that again. Florida, California and several other states have this program in place and it makes alot of work for both the insurance companies and consumers but they have less uninsured drivers and do not pay outrageous rates because everyone that cares is carrying other people. I work in the insurance industry and I have seen it all.

TexasGuyDFW read my blog view my photos
Feb 22, 2008 | 8:45 AM

I am just thinking everyone needs liability insurance just like everyone needs roads to drive on. Why not make it simple and fund it through a gasoline tax? No chasing anyone down, no worthless threats about revoking tags or license. They drive without insurance already, what is a lost license? After an accident, their having insurance is far more important to me than their having a valid license or tags.

We will also capture funds from out of state drivers, illegal aliens, rent cars, fugitives, etc... to help fund this program- which will be managed by any insurance company who writes in Texas. Much like state mandated workmans comp.

oldi read my blog view my photos
Feb 22, 2008 | 5:33 PM

The idiots that don't have insurance often get their cars towed and get the "Fail to Maintain Liability Insurance" tickets.
Those tickets are around $500.00 and more.
The impound fee is usually at least $100.00 and the towing is usually at least $45.00.
It is less expensive to have insurance.
People are just stupid to think that they can save money by not having insurance.

TexasGuyDFW read my blog view my photos
Feb 22, 2008 | 6:06 PM

oldi,

We are not dealing with Rocket Scientist here. they are told they must have insurance when they go to get 1) a license to drive, 2) a state inspection, 3) registration for their vehicle...

They are not told the penalties for not having it, many of them don't speak English or have any idea about our laws and customs. The ones that do tend to be shady in one way or another.

they go to the "$49.00" insurance places. this insurance is good for maybe a month, till the next payment is due. the next payment is never paid, nor is it expected to be. the insurance company doesn't really want this customer, they just want the $49 for the piece of paper that says they are insured. Is is a scam. OK? Even if the "insured" had an accident, they likely will RUN from the scene of the accident for fear of being DEPORTED. I have seen this happen, and I even chased the dudes into a neighborhood while I was on the phone with the police, who naturally did not get there in time to catch them. But they told me this was COMMON.

My plan INSURES everyone is INSURED. It forces everyone to buy insurance with every fill-up, or else they simply cannot drive! And those who drive more pay more, since they offer greater exposure to accidents (more miles driven).

Klutzy2508 read my blog view my photos
Feb 22, 2008 | 9:24 PM

Sounds good to me.

People are already complaining about the price of gasoline. What's another few cents to ensure that everyone has insurance.

TexasGuyDFW read my blog view my photos
Feb 23, 2008 | 3:00 AM

For those of us who actually PAY for insurance, our rates would come DOWN, and not in a small way. You see, we have a state board of insurance- it is a regulated industry in Texas. Rates are already somewhat controlled.

By forcing everyone to buy coverage- to "pay into the system" as it were, the rest of us who are carrying the burden for all these uninsured will see our rates fall dramatically. We wont even need "uninsured motorist" coverage any longer- although we might want a supplement if the lower limit is not high enough. Still that would be a whole lot cheaper than what we pay now.

Imagine this- even out of state drivers would be covered (secondarily, of course) by our own system while driving in Texas. Now we can have the State of Texas behind us when our insurance has to go after someone from out of state for non-payment of claims. An my plan impounds the "uninsured's" vehicle until a settlement is made. If the other party cant pay the claim (no insurance or too little insurance), the vehicle is auctioned and proceeds go to the victim. After all, it is a crime to not have insurance and drive.

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




TexasGuyDFW

Native Texan.... Fair and Biased... Yada, yada, yada... texas_guy_dfw@yahoo.com ...... Y'all come back now, y'hear!

Member Since: 7/13/2006