MyFox
 

p00frog

by p00frog from GP

Last Post 8 days, 22 hours Ago


18-year-olds are responsible enough to vote, to enlist in the military and to marry without parental consent … but not old enough to drink?

It sounds like a righteous argument – but is it really?

First, we must consider that these comparisons don’t even play ball in the same field. 18-year-olds don’t poison their bodies by voting too many times (as I understand it, your vote only counts once, doesn’t it? In some states, even if you’re dead)

Enlisting in the military is a serious commitment sometimes requiring weeks of counsel.

A game of beer pong may last 15 minutes.

And marriage, though it can also be jumped into without much thought (does “we were drunk” sound familiar?), is at least a commitment arranged by two, hopefully consenting, parties. And if alcohol does turn out to be a contributing factor in a shotgun wedding, the marriage can always be annulled (see: Britney weds in Las Vegas).

I could go dig up some research that spouts how many people have died as a result of underage drunken drivers – but such arguments have never appealed to me. Last time I used statistics as a foundational argument I was called names and banished from the playground by the other third graders. They didn’t like my presentation on how, statistically speaking, 24 cats probably did their business in the sandbox the night before.

“The very sand you currently have your hands in,” I told the young, naïve ears perking up at me, “has been, at some point or another, pooped in, on or around; if not by the neighborhood cats, then by Jill Macintosh.” (Jill was known around the playground to be portentously overblown.)

They then proceeded to throw some mysteriously-held-together clumps of sand at me. To this day I have not fully recovered.

But if I don’t use statistics, what then? Consider that myself, and my associates, were all at one time 18 years of age. Then consider the foolish things we did at 18 (too many to list here), and you are essentially left with a lopsided argument in favor of the current law.

Unless 18-year-olds have grown incredibly more mature in the few years since I was 18 – it is in our country’s best interest to keep the [legal] drinking age at 21.

I will, however, grant one exception. That exception being if an 18-year-old can stand in line at the DMV by themselves without any parental supervision, successfully pass a field sobriety test administered by the office clerk while sober (that’s you, not the clerk); the aforementioned, upon successful completion, will thereby be granted a 3 year stipulation in excess of his or her current age at the time of testing, thus rendering any law void and obsolete.

We all know those dagum field sobriety tests are impossible to pass anyway. Let’s utilize them to their fullest potential, fool the 18-year-olds into thinking there is hope for their cause, and we can go on being the responsible, over-the-legal-age citizens that we are.

Now pass me a beer – I have election coverage I need to catch up on.

16 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 16
Page 1 of 1
terrellmom read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 9:38 AM

poofrog...great blog! I'm with ya on this.

I'd rather my 18 yr old fight in Iraq than fight the war he/she will find in the bottom of that bottle

I'll never understand why ppl want their children to get drunk legally at 18

scottythecomic read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 3:35 PM

I say let 'em drink. If they are old enough to die they are old enough to drink. Responsibility and choices are always before a person, age notwithstanding. Moreover, alcohol is readily available underage or not.

terrellmom read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 3:50 PM

scotty, i'm afraid alot of people feel the way you do...so i'm sure the age will be lowered. follow the masses...surely you can't go wrong

p00frog read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 4:13 PM

scotty, you're right -- alcohol is a plenty regardless of age. I've been legal for a couple of years but have only purchased alcohol on a couple of occasions. Any other time it was made available to me.

If anything, let states decide without big brother twisting their arm one way or the other.

terrel, maybe they figure drunk legally is better than drunk illegally.

Marks read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 6:15 PM

If you join the military, you should be able to drink. Trust me, you will need it!

When I joined at 19 years old, we could drink on base. After a few short years, that was reversed. What happened after that was beer-bashes at the beach given by the more senior NCOs. Unfortunatly, this resulted in more DUI's and a worse record for the base.

Let 'em drink. They are protecting your country when on duty. Let them be when they are off duty.

Marks read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 6:21 PM

For the record, alcohol is not allowed on US Navy vessels except for very specific circumstances. When embarked, the ship could be on station for longer than 90 days without pulling into port, and sometimes a full (6-7 month) deployment would have a net amount of one week pier-side. Just a little downtime is better than none...

scottythecomic read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 8:07 PM

TM, my argument is thus: If you can die for this country, one should be able to drink.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with alcohol in moderation, but it is drunkenness we should be against.

Too, TM, if people want to drink they will no matter the age. I had my first drink, some apricot brandy, at age 13.

My agrument would be to let each state decide. I meanh why criminalize it?

Ironman read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 9:13 PM

It's not the parents who want their child to be able to drink legaly at 18, it's the alcohol companies that do. They don't give a rats BLEEP how many die. 85,000 a year last I heard, from alcohol. They want their mney, and the policicians want the lobbiest to keep their pockets fat. Send them an e-mail, letter, call them. Changing the drinking age to 18 is insanity.

scottythecomic read my blog view my photos
Sep 3, 2008 | 10:26 PM

Considering you're a big advocate of weed, don't you find that entirely hypocritical, Ironman?

Alcohol is a drug as is weed and cocaine et al.

moankie82 read my blog
Sep 4, 2008 | 5:38 AM

I don't believe the legal drinking age will ever be enforced at any age. If they want to drink they will. In the 60's we used to go to Louisiana because the age was 18. They will always find a way. Do I think its okay? No. But they will.

scottythecomic read my blog view my photos
Sep 4, 2008 | 6:29 AM

Either raise the age to join the military or lower the age to drink. That is, allow the voters to decide.

moankie82 read my blog
Sep 5, 2008 | 2:45 AM

Agreed scotty. It makes no sense to ask a man to die for his country, but tell him he can't have a beer.I to think the ages should be the same. Plus everyone underage that drinks does not have a problem eith the bottle.

scottythecomic read my blog view my photos
Sep 5, 2008 | 6:39 AM

I agree, moankie. People that want to drink will. My neighbor is 14 and drinks.

moankie82 read my blog
Sep 6, 2008 | 10:17 PM

To manu people have the idea that if you drink you will end up in trouble. That isn't true either.

scottythecomic read my blog view my photos
Sep 7, 2008 | 7:22 AM

In my wife's country anyone can but alcohol and drink it legally at any age. But guess what? The kids don't.

It seems to me that when we go forbiding some things that kids will do naturally out of curiosity, the more they will be inclined to step across that proverbial line in rebellion and try it anyway.

Drinking isn't a problem; drunkenness is.

moankie82 read my blog
Sep 8, 2008 | 12:37 AM

Agreed. And thats not to bad if you do it at home and don't hassel anyone. When I drink I always get happy. Never mean.

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




p00frog

I'm a local journalism major who doesn't take life too seriously. I like contagious laughter. I enjoy the freedom that accompanies summer, but equally enjoy the traditions and closeness fall and winter offer. I'm a procrastinator, but we'll talk more about that later.

Member Since: 8/22/2006